- You are here:
- Home »
- Non Toxic Nursery »
- Naturepedic vs. Newton Baby Crib Mattress: Which One is Better?
Naturepedic vs. Newton Baby Crib Mattress: A Comparative Review
As a parent or caregiver, one of the most pivotal decisions you can make is choosing the right crib mattress. We sweat the tiniest details when it comes to our babies, so here’s an extensive dive comparing two giants in the nursery world: the Naturepedic Breathable Baby Crib Mattress and the Newton Crib Mattress.
|
Best Overall
|
Best Budget-Friendly Option
|
|
4.5
|
4.0
|
|
$359
|
$299
|
|
|
|
|
Best Overall
4.5
$359
- Certified Organic Materials
- Greenguard GOLD and Made Safe Certified
- Dual Firmness Design
- Breathable
- 100-Day Trial
- Limited Lifetime Warranty
- Lightweight and Innespring Options Available
- Expensive
Best Budget-Friendly Option
4.0
$299
- Greenguard GOLD Certified
- Dual Firmness Design
- Unique Breathable Design Technology
- 100-Day Trial
- Limited Lifetime Warranty
- Synthetic Materials
- Harsh Surface
- Waterproof Cover Available at Extra Cost
The Showdown: Naturepedic vs. Newton Crib Mattress
Materials
The Naturepedic stands as a pioneer in using organic materials. Their GOTS certification and non-GMO sugarcane waterproof surface are testaments to their commitment. It even goes further with a breathable 3D lattice design, ideal for the most sensitive to allergens.
On the flip side, the Newton uses a unique blend of food-grade polymers and natural viscose for its core and cover, respectively. This innovative approach maps out a mattress that’s hypoallergenic and far from harmful chemicals, reinforcing your baby’s safety. The downside is that if you want a waterproof cover, you have to pay $50 extra.
The Verdict: Naturepedic shines with 100% organic materials, a waterproof cover included, and a more firm-side design, ideal for infants, while Newton opts for an unconventional, safety-first approach with its materials and breathability.
Winner
Naturepedic Organic Breathable Crib Mattress
$359
Pros:
- Certified Organic Materials
- Greenguard GOLD and Made Safe Certified
- Dual Firmness Design
- Breathable
- Waterproof
- 100-Day Trial
- Limited Lifetime Warranty
- Lightweight and Innespring Options Available
Cons:
- Price
- Synthetic materials in the cover
Safety
Both contenders hold prestigious certifications – Naturepedic with its Greenguard GOLD and Made Safe certifications, and Newton with its Greenguard GOLD – reinforcing their stance on health and environmental safety.
The Verdict: It’s a tie. Both manufacturers put extensive effort into ensuring their products are safe for your child and the planet.
Design and Comfort
Both mattresses offer dual-sided designs to cater to your baby’s different sleeping stages. Naturepedic comes with a firm side for newborns and a slightly softer side suitable for toddlers. It’s also available in two versions: Lightweight and Innerspring, so you have two different support options.
On the flip side, Newton offers a built-in dual-sided design. The patented Wovenaire core is firmer for newborns and gradually softens as your baby grows, maintaining optimal spinal alignment. Its exceptional breathability makes it ideal for hot sleepers and prevents SIDS.
The Verdict: Newton’s innovative design and breathability reigns supreme, although Naturepedic offers two versatile options to cater to your baby’s different sleeping stages.
Newton Baby Classic Crib Mattress
$299,99
Materials: Food-Grade Polymer, Polyester
Certificates: Greenguard GOLD
Maintenance
Both mattresses are washable, a godsend when you think of baby life. Naturepedic’s design allows for the cover to be machine washed, while Newton’s cowl is easily removable for a quick laundry day without having to stress about those tricky spots.
However, Naturepedic has a waterproof surface, making it easier to clean up accidents without having to strip off the entire cover.
The Verdict: Naturepedic’s removable waterproof cover and easy-to-clean design edges out Newton’s removable but non-waterproof cover.
Price
The price point inevitably comes into play. Naturepedic, with its 100% organic promise, comes at a premium. Newton, with its innovative design, is priced competitively for the value it offers. However, if you order Newton mattress with a waterproof cover, it will be only $10 cheaper than Naturepedic.
The Verdict: Your budget will dictate your path. If finances are a top concern, Newton emerges as a strong contender as long as you order the non-waterproof version. If you’re willing to invest in an organic and waterproof mattress, Naturepedic is a better option.
Warranty and Trial Period: Guarantees That Matter
Both mattresses come with a limited lifetime warranty, so you don’t have to worry about wear and tear. Both Newton and Naturepedic offer a 100-night trial period, where you can test out the mattress and return it for a full refund if unsatisfied.
The Verdict: It’s another tie. Both brands offer similar guarantees, making them both reliable options.
Considerations for Your Lifestyle and Values
Your lifestyle, values, and the unique needs of your baby will ultimately guide your choice.
For the Health-Focused: If health and well-being are non-negotiables for you and your baby, Naturepedic’s organic and chemical-free composition might be the decisive factor.
For the Technophile: Newton’s unique, innovative material choice and breathable design might resonate more with parents who appreciate technology in infant care products.
For the Budget Conscious: While both options hold their ground in the long run, Newton’s price tag is lighter, making it a favorable option for budget-oriented families.
For the Environmentally Concerned: Both companies operate with a strong focus on environmental sustainability, but Naturepedic’s commitment to organic and natural materials might be the deciding factor.
Read More: Best Organic Crib Mattresses
Analysis of Customer Reviews
In assessing the customer reviews for both mattresses, it’s clear that each has its supporters and areas of improvement. On the whole, both mattresses are praised for their non-toxic materials and comfort level.
However, some parents have noted that the Newton mattress releases an initial smell upon unboxing, while others mention that the mattress surface may be too hard for their child’s sensitive skin.
On the other hand, some parents have found that the Naturepedic mattress seems to sink on one side after extended use. However, most reviews are positive, and both brands have an overall satisfaction rate of over 90%.
Winner
Naturepedic Organic Breathable Crib Mattress
$359
Pros:
- Certified Organic Materials
- Greenguard GOLD and Made Safe Certified
- Dual Firmness Design
- Breathable
- Waterproof
- 100-Day Trial
- Limited Lifetime Warranty
- Lightweight and Innespring Options Available
Cons:
- Price
- Synthetic materials in the cover
Read More: Top Tips for a Toxin-Free Nursery
Best Alternatives
While the Naturepedic and Newton mattresses are top contenders in the organic and breathable crib mattress market, there are other options worth considering.
Here are a few alternatives to look into:
- Babyletto Pure Core Non-Toxic Crib Mattress: This mattress is Greenguard GOLD certified, but it’s not organic. It offers a waterproof surface and dual-sided firmness for infants and toddlers.
- Emily Crib Mattress: This organic mattress offers a 100% natural, comfortable, hypoallergenic design. It comes at a more affordable price point than the Naturepedic and Newton mattresses, but it’s non-waterproof.
Conclusion: Which Mattress Will It Be?
In conclusion, when deciding between Naturepedic and Newton for your baby’s crib mattress, your choice hinges on personal priorities and values.
If your paramount concern is health and you are committed to an organic lifestyle, then Naturepedic is the superior choice. It pledges utmost safety and eco-friendliness with 100% organic components, steering clear of any potentially harmful chemicals. Despite being slightly more costly, its virtues align harmoniously with conscientious parenting.
Winner
Naturepedic Organic Breathable Crib Mattress
$359
Pros:
- Certified Organic Materials
- Greenguard GOLD and Made Safe Certified
- Dual Firmness Design
- Breathable
- Waterproof
- 100-Day Trial
- Limited Lifetime Warranty
- Lightweight and Innespring Options Available
Cons:
- Price
- Synthetic materials in the cover
On the flip side, if budget constraints loom large, and you are seeking value for money without compromising on innovation and design, the Newton mattress stands out as a budget-wise alternative. Balancing price with quality, it offers a practical choice for those who desire safety and comfort yet must adhere to stricter financial considerations.
Best Budget-Friendly Option
Newton Crib Mattress
$299
Pros:
- Greenguard GOLD Certified
- Dual Firmness Design
- Unique Breathable Design Technology
- 100-Day Trial
- Limited Lifetime Warranty
Cons:
- Synthetic Materials
- Harsh Surface
- Waterproof Cover Available at Extra Cost
Read More: Best Non-Toxic Cribs
About the Author Kamila Flieger
My name is Kamila, and I'm passionate about researching non-toxic, organic products for the home. I believe it's so important to create a safe and healthy environment for our families, and I enjoy helping others do the same.
