Avocado vs Naturepedic Crib Mattress: A Guide for New Parents

 

In this extensive comparison, we delve into two industry-leading crib mattresses, Avocado and Naturepedic, to help you make an informed decision. Each brand brings unique features to the table, designed to offer a blend of comfort, safety, and sustainable ethos.

Let’s weigh the materials, certifications, comfort levels, and price points to see which mattress stands out for a variety of eco-friendly criteria.

 

Winner
 
$359
$439
  • Certified Organic Materials
  • Greenguard GOLD and Made Safe Certified
  • Dual Firmness Design
  • Breathable
  • Waterproof
  • 100-Day Trial
  • Limited Lifetime Warranty
  • Lightweight and Innespring Options Available
  • Certified Organic Materials
  • Greenguard GOLD and Made Safe Certified
  • Dual Firmness Design
  • Breathable
  • 30-Day Trial
  • 25-Year Warranty
  • Polyester in the cover
  • Price
  • Not Waterproof
Winner
$359
  • Certified Organic Materials
  • Greenguard GOLD and Made Safe Certified
  • Dual Firmness Design
  • Breathable
  • Waterproof
  • 100-Day Trial
  • Limited Lifetime Warranty
  • Lightweight and Innespring Options Available
  • Polyester in the cover
$439
  • Certified Organic Materials
  • Greenguard GOLD and Made Safe Certified
  • Dual Firmness Design
  • Breathable
  • 30-Day Trial
  • 25-Year Warranty
  • Price
  • Not Waterproof

 

The Eco-Friendly Crib Mattress Battleground

 

The Avocado Organic Crib Mattress and the Naturepedic Crib Mattress are crafted with the environment in mind. Both companies have garnered a stellar reputation for their commitment to using natural, sustainably sourced materials.

The focus on certifications that assure safety and ecological responsibility is a common thread, but how do they differ in execution?

 

Materials and Features

 

The Avocado Crib Mattress boasts a dual-sided design tailored for both infants and toddlers. Handcrafted in Los Angeles, it is made with GOTS wool, GOLS latex, and organic coconut husk fiber.

This combination offers resilient yet gentle support for your infant, later transitioning to a more buoyant surface for the growing toddler. It’s a mattress designed to grow with your child, a feature that resonates with many sustainability-minded parents.

However, its heavy weight may be a concern for some, and the lack of built-in waterproofing requires an additional investment in crib mattress protection.

On the other hand, the Naturepedic Crib Mattress offers two types of support WaveSupport technology (more lightweight) or innersprings, enclosed in a structure that facilitates airflow around the entire mattress.

The materials are waterproof and wipe-clean, offering practicality alongside the promise of a non-toxic, organic product. The lightweight qualities make it easier to change sheets and manage the mattress during daily routines.

However, we don’t like the fact that this mattress uses sugarcane-derived polyester in its cover, which may not align with the values of some eco-conscious parents, but this kind of synthetic material is fully biodegradable and breathable.

 

Read More: Naturepedic vs Newton Baby Mattress

 

Comfort and Support

 

Comfort and support are non-negotiables when it comes to your baby’s crib mattress. Avocado’s focus on organic, hand-picked materials means a carefully calibrated balance of firmness and breathability. Parents praise its consistent support and the peace of mind that comes from using an entirely vegan bedding choice.

Naturepedic doesn’t shy away from the comfort game either, combining sturdy support with an emphasis on breathability. Its performance in official test conditions for crib mattress breathability highlights its commitment to a sleeping surface that promotes healthy air circulation and a safer environment for your infant.

 

Price Point and Additional Benefits

 

Avocado is quite expensive, costing around $430. The dual-sided feature, the 25-year warranty and 30-day sleep trial are compelling arguments, cushioning the initial investment as a commitment to long-term sustainability and comfort.

Naturepedic is not only competitive in its price point but also emphasizes versatility in its product range. apart from offering a two-stage mattress, the company provides lightweight and innerspring alternatives, catering to various preferences without compromising on its stringent standards.

They offer a better warranty policy (Limited Lifetime) and longer sleep trial period than Avocado, responding to customer feedback with a stronger customer-centric approach.

Winner
 
$359
$439
  • Certified Organic Materials
  • Greenguard GOLD and Made Safe Certified
  • Dual Firmness Design
  • Breathable
  • Waterproof
  • 100-Day Trial
  • Limited Lifetime Warranty
  • Lightweight and Innespring Options Available
  • Certified Organic Materials
  • Greenguard GOLD and Made Safe Certified
  • Dual Firmness Design
  • Breathable
  • 30-Day Trial
  • 25-Year Warranty
  • Polyester in the cover
  • Price
  • Not Waterproof
Winner
$359
  • Certified Organic Materials
  • Greenguard GOLD and Made Safe Certified
  • Dual Firmness Design
  • Breathable
  • Waterproof
  • 100-Day Trial
  • Limited Lifetime Warranty
  • Lightweight and Innespring Options Available
  • Polyester in the cover
$439
  • Certified Organic Materials
  • Greenguard GOLD and Made Safe Certified
  • Dual Firmness Design
  • Breathable
  • 30-Day Trial
  • 25-Year Warranty
  • Price
  • Not Waterproof

 

A Closer Look at Certifications

 

When it comes to shopping for an eco-friendly crib mattress, certifications can act as a roadmap to the mattress’s environmental merit. Both Avocado and Naturepedic have an impressive array of certifications that testify to their ecological alignment.

 

Avocado’s Certifications

 

Avocado’s crib mattress is a cornucopia of certifications: MadeSafe™, Greenguard Gold, GOTS, GOLS, and FSC. These certifications represent endorsements from leading environmental and health organizations, guaranteeing that the mattress meets the strictest criteria for quality, sustainability, and safety.

 

Naturepedic’s Accreditations

 

Naturepedic doesn’t shy away from the certifications game, either, with GOTS, Greenguard GOLD and Made Safe among its accolades. Furthermore, the acclaim for its products extends beyond the mattress, encompassing the company’s entire philosophy of providing organic sleep solutions for the whole family.

The comprehensive approach to environmental responsibility is clearly outlined, reinforcing the brand image as a trailblazer in the eco-friendly sleep sector.

 

Read More: Best Affordable Non-Toxic Baby Cribs

 

Making the Choice

 

While both Avocado and Naturepedic offer credible eco-conscious crib mattress options, Naturepedic stands out as an exemplary choice for several reasons:

  • The brand’s focus on harnessing technology for comfort and safety, such as its proprietary WaveSupport feature, guarantees a sturdy yet gentle sleeping surface for infants.
  • The practical benefits of its waterproof and easy-to-clean design simplify the daily lives of busy parents, reducing the need for additional mattress protection and facilitating effortless maintenance.
  • Naturepedic addresses a wider audience by offering a range of products, including lightweight and innerspring models, ensuring there is a perfect fit for varying preferences without compromising on ecological or health standards.
  • Their crib mattresses are cheaper without sacrificing quality, making Naturepedic a budget-friendly and sustainable choice for eco-conscious parents.
  • Naturepedic is a vegan crib mattress that aligns with the values of many sustainability-minded parents.
  • Naturpedic warranty and sleep trial period are longer and more customer-centric compared to Avocado.

 

Winner
 
$359
$439
  • Certified Organic Materials
  • Greenguard GOLD and Made Safe Certified
  • Dual Firmness Design
  • Breathable
  • Waterproof
  • 100-Day Trial
  • Limited Lifetime Warranty
  • Lightweight and Innespring Options Available
  • Certified Organic Materials
  • Greenguard GOLD and Made Safe Certified
  • Dual Firmness Design
  • Breathable
  • 30-Day Trial
  • 25-Year Warranty
  • Polyester in the cover
  • Price
  • Not Waterproof
Winner
$359
  • Certified Organic Materials
  • Greenguard GOLD and Made Safe Certified
  • Dual Firmness Design
  • Breathable
  • Waterproof
  • 100-Day Trial
  • Limited Lifetime Warranty
  • Lightweight and Innespring Options Available
  • Polyester in the cover
$439
  • Certified Organic Materials
  • Greenguard GOLD and Made Safe Certified
  • Dual Firmness Design
  • Breathable
  • 30-Day Trial
  • 25-Year Warranty
  • Price
  • Not Waterproof

 

Final Thoughts on Naturepedic vs Avocado Crib Mattresses

 

While both brands offer excellent options for eco-conscious parents, Naturepedic stands out as the better choice due to its innovative technology, versatility, and commitment to sustainability. Its certifications and awards speak volumes about the brand’s dedication to providing organic sleep solutions that are safe, comfortable, and practical.

With a more customer-centric approach and budget-friendly pricing, Naturepedic is the clear winner in the Naturepedic vs Avocado organic crib mattress comparison.

So why wait? Invest in a Naturepedic crib mattress today and give your little one the gift of healthy, restful sleep on an eco-friendly surface. After all, a good night’s sleep for your baby means a well-rested and happy family!

 

Winner
Naturepedic Organic Breathable Crib Mattress
$359



Pros:
  • Certified Organic Materials
  • Greenguard GOLD and Made Safe Certified
  • Dual Firmness Design
  • Breathable
  • Waterproof
  • 100-Day Trial
  • Limited Lifetime Warranty
  • Lightweight and Innespring Options Available
Cons:
  • Price
  • Synthetic materials in the cover

About the Author Kamila Flieger

My name is Kamila, and I'm passionate about researching non-toxic, organic products for the home. I believe it's so important to create a safe and healthy environment for our families, and I enjoy helping others do the same.

follow me on:

Leave a Comment: