13 Types of Pillow Stuffing: Which One Is The Best?
Disclaimer: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Pillows are essential for a comfortable night of sleep. They provide back, head and neck support to help you get the rest that your body needs. Many different types of pillows are on the market today, making it difficult to choose one if you´re looking for a perfect new pillow and want to make one from scratch.
The most common filling types include feather pillows, synthetic fiber pillows, buckwheat hull pillows, memory foam or latex pillows. Each type has its own unique pros and cons, so here we discuss 13 different types of pillow stuffing options to help you decide which is best for you.
Best Natural Stuffing for Pillows
One pillow stuffing option that is becoming more and more popular is the natural stuffing for your pillow. This includes materials like wool, cotton, feathers, and down. There are many benefits to using natural stuffing materials, including being hypoallergenic, eco-friendly, and providing superior comfort.
This stuffing is recommended for children, people with allergies and chemical sensitivities, and anyone who wants to cut their exposure to toxic chemicals that may be released by conventional synthetic pillows. Let’s take a closer look at some of the best natural materials for your pillow.
Latex Pillow Filling
Latex fill is one of the most recommended natural pillow fillings, it’s thanks to its hypoallergenic properties and springiness. Latex is a natural product made of sap from rubber trees, which means that it has the same benefits as rubber, such as durability and elasticity.
Latex pillows are very breathable because the air circulates easily in them, regardless of whether you choose the solid latex or shredded latex option.
They are also pressure-relieving because they have no hard parts inside that could press against your head or neck when you lie on the pillow, which makes them great for side sleepers. Latex filling has natural anti-bacterial and anti-fungal properties.
If you suffer from asthma or allergies, a latex pillow is a perfect choice for you because it doesn’t retain moisture and is resistant to mold and mildew. Choose GOLS certified latex, which is guaranteed to contain 95% organic latex, free from toxic chemicals.
Pros
- Great for allergies, asthma sufferers
- Resistant to mold/mildew/dust mites
- Breathable and pressure-relieving
- Always retains its shape
Cons
- More expensive than most other pillow types
- Not all manufacturers offer 100% natural latex pillows, so it’s best to buy GOLS certified organic latex.
Washing Instructions: A latex pillow should not be machine washed as it can get easily damaged. You can hand wash and spot-clean the casing.
|
|
|
|
$104.95
|
N/A
|
$109
|
Read More: Are Latex Pillows Good?
Buckwheat Hull Pillow Filling
Buckwheat Pillow Filling is made from 100% buckwheat hulls. Buckwheat pillows are naturally hypoallergenic, dust mite resistant, and wick away moisture. Due to their firmness and malleability, buckwheat pillows are a great option for side sleepers because they can provide a lot of support.
This natural pillow fill is also recommended for hot sleepers in the summer months as it is very breathable and keeps the sleeper cool.
Pros
- Offers plenty of head and neck support
- Promotes air flow (ideal choice for hot sleepers)
- It’s moldable
- It has no odor or chemical smell
Cons
- Buckwheat hulls can make a rustling noise when you move in your sleep
- Some people find it too firm
- This type of filling is quite heavy
Washing Instructions: Buckwheat hull fill should never come in direct contact with water. Spot-clean the casing when it gets stained and protect your buckwheat pillow with a pillow protector.
|
|
|
|
N/A
|
$129.00
|
$41.00
|
Millet Pillow Stuffing
Millet pillow stuffing is made up of millet hulls. This type of pillow filling provides airy support and allows for ease of movement. Millet hull filling is inexpensive, though not as cheap as polyester filling. Millet hulls are naturally soft, smooth, and pliable making them great pillows that are also eco-friendly and biodegradable.
Millet hull pillows are commonly used as an alternative to down and foam pillows because they provide similar support without animal byproducts. Millet hulls offer support that keeps one’s neck in a neutral position, such as when sleeping on one’s side or stomach. This pillow fill has similar properties to buckwheat but is much more lightweight.
Pros
- Hypoallergenic, biodegradable and durable
- Will contour to the shape of your head, providing excellent head and neck support
Cons
- Not as firm as polyester or down pillows
- May release a wheat-like smell for a few weeks
- The hulls may get compressed after a few years of use, but it can be fixed by adding extra stuffing and fluffing the pillow regularly
- It may produce a rustling noise when you move
Washing Instructions: It’s a good idea to remove the filling before washing your pillow as millet hulls should never get wet. Allow the filling to breathe before reinserting it into a clean pillow.
|
|
|
|
$30.28
|
$65.99
|
N/A
|
Kapok Pillow Stuffing
Natural kapok is harvested from the seeds of the kapok tree. It looks like cotton but is silkier, lending it its name of “silk cotton” which offers a comfortable and airy feel. Kapok has a unique blend of heat-, moisture-, and mold-resistant fibers, making it better than most pillow stuffing options.
This pillow filling is hypoallergenic and can breathe easily, allowing air to move freely inside the pillow for a comfortable sleeping environment. So if you are looking for a good pillow stuffing material that is free of chemicals and other toxins, then a kapok pillow should be your choice.
Pros
- It’s hypoallergenic and biodegradable
- Kapok pillows are very breathable and great for hot sleepers.
- Free from animal products, a great choice for vegans
Cons
- Kapok pillows are not moldable so they won’t adapt to your shape
- Kapok can become lumpy and need fluffing and shaking regularly, which makes the pillow less durable than other filling types
Washing Instructions: Kapok fill can be easily damaged when it becomes wet, so it’s best to wash only the cotton shell and leave the filling in direct sunlight for a few hours to air it and naturally sanitize it.
|
|
|
|
|
$92.00
|
N/A
|
Down Pillow Stuffing
Down pillow stuffing is a great choice for any sleeper. This material is generally made from goose or duck down and they are some of the softest stuffing options available.
Down pillows are lightweight, breathable, durable and supportive without being too firm or too lofty. They offer the right amount of support to help you get the rest your body needs.
Most down fillings are hypoallergenic and dust-mite resistant. It´s not water-resistant, so keep in mind that these pillows need to be cared for properly, or they will develop mold. This type of pillow is also more expensive than most other fillings due to the high-quality materials used.
Pros
- Lightweight, soft, and comfortable
- Hypoallergenic and dust mite-resistant
Cons
- Down pillows should be taken care of properly so they do not lose their firmness or support.
- More costly than other fillings
- May involve animal cruelty if down is obtained from live-plucking
Cleaning and Care: Down pillows should be washed and dried on a gentle cycle and then air-dried. Fluff your down pillow every other day or so to allow even distribution of the filling material and prevent clumping.
|
|
|
|
N/A
|
N/A
|
$79.99
|
Wool Pillow Stuffing
Wool pillow stuffing is great for regulating moisture, keeping you dry and fresh all night long while maintaining a neutral body temperature. These hypoallergenic pillows will keep you cool in summer and warm on cold winter nights. Wool pillows are fluffier than other types of fiber which means they have less springiness to them.
Read More: Wool Pillows Pros and Cons
On the other hand, they are quite delicate and should always be checked for proper care instructions before purchase. Natural wool pillows lose their puff over time, so it’s advisable to re-fluff them once daily to retain their shape.
Pros
- Good at regulating moisture and temperature
- Keeps you cool in summer and warm on winter nights
Cons
- Some wool pillows may have a distinct odor
- Over time, wool becomes lumpy.
- It will not maintain its shape, and it is not pliable
- It may involve animal cruelty
Washing Instructions: Wool pillows are delicate and should always be checked for proper care instructions before purchase.
|
|
|
|
|
$89
|
$158
|
Feather Pillow Stuffing
Feather Pillow Stuffing is another hypoallergenic choice. Although there is some controversy surrounding the cruelty of goose and duck farming, most major retailers offer feather pillows obtained from animals not live-plucked or force-fed animals.
These materials tend to be very fluffy and soft, making them a great option for anyone who prefers a firm pillow with a lot of support.
Feather pillows are not water-resistant and most down-proof pillowcases can be used with these pillows to cut down on cleaning time and prevent damage from mold build-up. This type of filling is high quality, durable, versatile, and affordable.
Pros
- Feather pillows are soft and comfortable
- Affordable and durable
- Good for people who prefer firm pillows with a lot of support.
- Feathers are hypoallergenic and dust-mite resistant.
Cons
- May involve animal cruelty if down is obtained from live-plucking
- A feather pillow is not very lofty or puffy.
- May be difficult to fluff regularly due to their flatness.
Cleaning and Care: To maintain the quality of your feather pillow it should be washed in cold water on a gentle cycle with delicate laundry detergent.
Materials: 85% Goose Feather, 15% Goose Down, Oeko-Tex Certified Cotton
Cotton Pillow Stuffing
Cotton pillow fillings contain a bunch of short and long-stranded fibers that are pulled, twisted, and bonded together. Cotton material is cheap, and it’s easy to find GOTS certified organic cotton filling that is chemical-free as well as pesticide-free, making it a great choice to use in pillows for children as their skin is more sensitive than adults.
Since cotton is a natural product, it has some drawbacks too. Pillows filled with 100% cotton may be harder than pillows filled with other materials, they are also prone to compression and lumps so they do not keep their shape well.
As they absorb moisture very well, they may become moldy over time, which makes cotton fill the least desirable pillow filling out of all-natural options.
Pros
- Hypoallergenic
- Breathable
- Moisture-wicking
- GOTS-certified cotton filling is free from toxic chemicals
Cons
- Pillows made with 100% cotton fill are less supportive than pillows filled with other materials.
- They are also prone to compression and lumps so they do not keep their shape well.
- As they easily absorb moisture, they may develop odor over time and become unhygienic.
Washing Instructions: Never use hot water with cotton, or else it will shrink. Machine wash in cold or lukewarm water along with other pillow stuffings and mild detergent to keep your pillows naturally clean.
PLA Stuffing
PLA (polylactic acid) is a great alternative to polyester. PLA is a natural filling material, a renewable resource and biodegradable. PLA stuffing material is made from plants, not plastic, making it safe for our environment.
PLA pillow stuffing provides plenty of support and as its fibers are as resilient as polyester, it´s bound to last. These pillows also have excellent moisture-wicking properties, making them ideal for people who tend to sleep hot and sweat at night.
Pros
- Environmentally friendly
- Non-hazardous to health
Cons
- PLA stuffing may lose its fluffiness over time, flatten out, and become harder
Washing Instructions: This pillow is machine washable, make sure to refill it after drying it.
Hemp Pillow Fill
Hemp pillow fill is antibacterial, anti-allergenic and very sturdy. Hemp is most often used for rope and fabric, but it’s also a great filler material. Hemp filling for pillows is sustainable and environmentally friendly.
It absorbs moisture and sweat quickly and prevents the formation of mold, fungi and bacteria. This hypoallergenic pillow filling prevents allergies and respiratory problems such as asthma.
Pros
- Soft, but provides enough comfort and support
- Malleable pillow fill, perfect for side sleepers
- Mildew- and fungi-resistant
- Wicks away moisture and allows air to circulate freely
- Sustainable and eco-friendly
Cons
- Hemp filling may feel rough and firm at the beginning, give it a few nights and it will become much softer
Washing Instructions: Hemp will be tuned when it comes in contact with water. You can only wash the casing using a mild detergent.
Synthetic Stuffing for Pillows
There are many different types of synthetic pillow fillings on the market these days, each with its own set of pros and cons. In this section, we’re going to look at the different types of synthetic pillow materials and their benefits, so you can decide if they are the right choice for you.
Polyester Fiberfill Pillow Stuffing
Polyester pillow stuffing is affordable, easy to maintain, machine washable, and it’s one of the best fillings for outdoor pillows. A polyester fiberfill pillow provides good support for restful sleep in different sleeping positions, however, polyester tends to compress and become lumpy pretty fast.
Poly-fil is not the right pillow type for hot sleepers as it retains body heat. Polyester is also used in down alternative pillows for people who are allergic to down or don’t want to buy animal products. While it’s much cheaper than down, it’s not nearly as durable and compresses pretty fast.
Pros
- Machine washable
- Good choice for people with allergies
- Polyester filling is inexpensive and easy to find
Cons
- Polyester fiberfill doesn’t fluff back up well after being compressed and easily becomes lumpy
- As it retains heat, it’s not recommended for hot sleepers
- Polyester fibers are a source of microplastics, so it’s not environmentally friendly
Washing instructions: Machine wash using warm water, re-fluff after drying.
Solid and Shredded Memory Foam Pillow Stuffing
Memory foam is a popular pillow filling material made from expanding polyurethane foam that can be seen in mattresses and couches. It’s available in two types of pillow stuffing, solid and shredded memory foam. While a solid memory foam pillow provides firm support and high loft, a shredded memory foam pillow is more fluffy and malleable.
Memory foam pillows are engineered to provide excellent pressure relief and restful sleep. However, this synthetic filling option may retain heat, so it’s not recommended for hot sleepers.
If you choose memory foam pillow fill, make sure that it’s CertiPUR certified. This certificate ensures that the pillow doesn’t release high amounts of VOCs and other toxic chemicals.
Pros
- Comfortable and available in different firmness levels
- Long-lasting and durable
- A solid memory foam pillow will always hold its shape
- Won’t become lumpy over time
Cons
- Not recommended for people with chemical sensitivities as they may contain toxic materials and release a strong chemical odor
- Retains body heat, not a good choice for the summer or hot sleepers
- Quite expensive compared to other pillow filling types
- It’s not eco-friendly as it’s made from petroleum-based polyurethane
Care Instructions: Unless it is explicitly stated otherwise, memory foam pillows should not be washed. Memory foam acts like a sponge, so putting it in a washing machine will ruin it and make it prone to developing mold. You should only spot-clean your memory foam pillow if it’s necessary.
Microbeads Pillow Stuffing
Microbeads are made from plastic or polyesteryne. Some of these beads are made from recycled plastic, making them more sustainable than other synthetic pillow filling types. They are known for their durability and affordability, as well as softness.
Microbead pillows are pliable and provide comfort to users. They are durable because they will not flatten easily, but tend to maintain their shape. This makes them great for stomach sleepers and back sleepers alike.
Pros
- Microbead pillows are lightweight and pack well for travel.
- The firmness makes them great to use to elevate your head when reading or watching TV.
- Many users of microbead pillows say they are able to sleep more deeply with them because the firmness encourages their bodies to relax fully.
- They are also hypoallergenic and resistant to dust mites, mold, mildew, and bugs.
- The pillow will retain its original shape for years to come
Cons
- The biggest complaint about microbead pillows is that they can be too firm for some users.
- There may be a chemical odor when using them for the first time.
- They may be releasing toxic chemicals
- They also retain heat, so you may wake up sweaty if you use one.
- They’re not biodegradable so they can be harmful to the environment.
Care Instructions: Keeping your microbead pillow clean and fresh is critical. Wash it in a gentle wash cycle in warm water with a mild laundry detergent.
Conclusion
There is no one “best” pillow filling. The best types of pillow stuffing for you depend on a number of factors, including your sleeping position and personal preference. As every sleeper is different, the only way to find out what’s the best pillow stuffing material for you is to try several options.
We always recommend choosing natural pillow filling over synthetic one, because it is both healthier and kinder to the environment. When you shop for your next pillow, keep in mind that not all natural materials are created equal.
Make sure that the stuffing you choose is GOTS or GOLS-certified organic and has a 100% cotton cover to ensure that it’s completely free from VOCs, bleach and other chemicals.
If you´ve got any questions or suggestions regarding pillow stuffing options, please use our comment section below.
